2018 Gaylord Perry
2017 Ferguson Jenkins
2016 Rollie Fingers
2015 Dale Murphy
2014 Bobby Richardson
2013 Bill Buckner
2012 Lance Parrish
2011 Doc Gooden
2010 Rick Dempsey
2009 Harmon Killebrew
2008 Orestes Destrade
2007 R. A. Dickey
2006 Joe West
2005 Steve Liddle
2004 Steve Lyons
2003 Tim Corbin
2002 Scott Sanderson
2001 Jim Cosman
2000 Buck O'Neil, Bill White
1999 Rick Honeycutt
1998 Gene Lamont
1997 Paul Snyder
1996 George Digby
1995 Scotti Madison
1994 Tommy Lasorda
1993 Bill Gullickson
1992 Buck Showalter
1991 Bob Quinn
1990 Syd Thrift
1989 Frank Lucchesi
1988 Phil Niekro
1987 Bob Montgomery
1986 Dave Bristol
1985 Ed Bailey
1984 Lefty Gomez
1983 Bob Turley, Russ Nixon
1982 Whitey Ford
1981 Mel Allen
1980 George Steinbrenner
1979 Joe Nuxhall
1978 Lefty Gomez
1977 Carl Sawatski
1976 Rip Sewell
1975 Smoky Burgess
1974 Ralph Houk, Lee MacPhail
1973 Harry Walker
1972 Bob Feller
1971 Bob Ueker
1970 Rube Walker
1969 Milo Hamilton
1968 Eddie Stanky
1967 Ernie Johnson
1966 Bobby Bragan
1965 Eddie Glennon
1964 Dixie Walker
1963 John Fitzgerald
1962 Larry Goetz
1961 Del Wilber
1960 Kerby Farrell
1959 Buddy Blattner
1958 Jimmy Dykes
1957 Kerby Farrell
1956 Gabe Paul
1955 Joe Engel
1954 Rip Collins
1953 Eddie Glennon
1952 Hugh Poland, Hub Perdue